按键盘上方向键 ← 或 → 可快速上下翻页，按键盘上的 Enter 键可回到本书目录页，按键盘上方向键 ↑ 可回到本页顶部！
————未阅读完？加入书签已便下次继续阅读！
own baseness； than owe their lives to the virtue of their neighbours。 So
true is it that the mass of pleasures are but evil；＇16＇ to which men succumb；
and thereby are incited to adopt the worse cause in speech and course in
63
… Page 64…
The Sportsman
action。＇17＇ And with what result？from vain and empty arguments they
contract emnities； and reap the fruit of evil deeds； diseases； losses； death
to the undoing of themselves； their children； and their friends。＇18＇ Having
their senses dulled to things evil； while more than commonly alive to
pleasures； how shall these be turned to good account for the salvation of
the state？ Yet from these evils every one will easily hold aloof； if once
enamoured of those joys whose brief I hold； since a chivalrous education
teaches obedience to laws； and renders justice familiar to tongue and
ear。＇19＇
＇16＇ See 〃Hellenica Essays；〃 p。 371。
＇17＇ 〃To depravity of speech and conduct〃 （whether as advocates or
performers）。 See Aristoph。 〃Clouds。〃
＇18＇ Or； 〃bring down on themselves； their children； and their friends
a spring of misfortunes in the shape of diseases； losses； or even
death。〃
＇19＇ 〃For what does a chivalrous education teach save to obey the law；
and to make the theme of justice familiar to tongue and ear？〃
In the one camp are those who； subjecting themselves ever to new toil
and fresh instruction； have； at the cost of lessons and exercises painful to
themselves； obtained to their several states salvation； and in the other are
those who for the very irksomeness of the process choose not to be taught；
but rather to pass away their days in pleasures unseasonablenature's
abjects these。＇20＇ Not theirs is it to obey either laws or good
instruction；＇21＇ nay； how should they； who never toil； discover what a
good man ought to be？in other words； wisdom and justice are alike
beyond their power。 Subject to indiscipline； they have many a fault to find
with him who is well educated。
＇20＇ Lit。 〃the sorriest of mankind these by nature。〃
＇21＇ Or； 〃virtuous argument〃； ｛logois agathois｝； lit。 〃good words。〃
Through the instrumentality of such as these nothing can go well；
whereas every blessing which mankind enjoys has been discovered by the
efforts of the nobler sort。 Nobler； I say； are those who choose to toil。＇22＇
＇22＇ Or； 〃of choice spirits； and who are the choice spirits？Clearly
those who choose to toil。〃
64
… Page 65…
The Sportsman
And this has been proved conclusively by a notable example。 If we
look back to the men of old who sat at the feet of Cheironwhose names I
mentionedwe see that it was by dedicating the years of their youth to the
chase＇23＇ that they learnt all their noble lore； and therefrom they attained
to great renown； and are admired even to this day for their virtuevirtue
who numbers all men as her lovers； as is very plain。 Only because of the
pains it costs to win her the greater number fall away； for the achievement
of her is hid in obscurity； while the pains that cleave to her are manifest。
Perchance； if only she were endowed with a visible bodily frame； men
would less have neglected her； knowing that even as she is visible to them；
so they also are not hid from her eyes。 For is it not so that when a man
moves in the presence of him whom he dearly loves；＇24＇ he rises to a
height above himself； being incapable of aught base or foul in word or
deed in sight of him？＇25＇ But fondly dreaming that the eye of virtue is
closed to them； they are guilty of many a base thing and foul before her
very face； who is hidden from their eyes。 Yet she is present everywhere；
being dowered with immortality； and those who are perfect in
goodness＇26＇ she honours； but the wicked she thrusts aside from honour。
If only men could know that she regards them； how eagerly would they
rush to the embrace of toilful training and tribulation；＇27＇ by which alone
she is hardly taken； and so should they gain the mastery over her； and she
should be laid captive at their feet。
＇23＇ Or； 〃that they made their first essay in hunting when mere boys；
and from hunting upwards were taught many noble arts。〃
＇24＇ Lit。 〃is beheld by his beloved。〃 Cf。 〃Symp。〃 iv。 4； viii。 31。
＇25＇ Lit。 〃in order not to be seen of him。〃
＇26＇ Lit。 〃good with respect to her。〃
＇27＇ Or； 〃to those toils and that training。〃
65
… Page 66…
The Sportsman
XIII
Now what astonishes me in the 〃sophists；〃 as they are called；＇1＇ is；
that though they profess； the greater part of them； to lead the young to
virtue； they really lead them in the opposite direction。 Never have we set
eyes on the man anywhere who owed his goodness to the sophists of to…
day。＇2＇ Nor do their writings contain anything＇3＇ calculated to make men
good； but they have written volumes on vain and frivolous subjects； in
which the young may find pleasures that pall； but the essence of virtue is
not in them。 The result of this literature is to inflict unncessary waste of
time on those who look to learn something from it all and look in vain；
cutting them off from wholesome occupations and even teaching what is
bad。 I cannot then but blame them for certain large offences＇4＇ more than
lightly； but as regards the subject matter of their writings my charge is；
that while full of far…fetched phraseology；＇5＇ of solid wholesome
sentiments； by which the young might be trained to virtue； I see not a
vestige。 Speaking as a plain man； I know that to be taught what is good by
one's own nature is best of all；＇6＇ and next best to learn of those who
really do know some good thing rather than of those who have an art to
deceive。 It may well be that I fail to express myself in subtle language；＇7＇
nor do I pretend to aim at subtlety； what I do aim at is to express rightly…
conceived thoughts such as may serve the need of those who have been
nobly disciplined in virtue； for it is not words and names that give
instruction； but thoughts and sentiments worthy the name。
＇1＇ Cf。 Isocr。 〃Against the Sophists〃； 〃Antidosis〃； 〃Hel。 Encom。〃；
Plat。 〃Sophist。〃
＇2＇ Who are these ｛oi nun sophistai｝？
＇3＇ Lit。 〃do they present writings to the world。〃
＇4＇ Or； 〃as to certain weightier matters gravely。〃
＇5＇ ｛remata｝ = 〃words and phrases〃； ｛ynomai｝ = 〃moral maxims； just
thoughts。〃
＇6＇ 〃Being myself but a private individual and a plain man。〃 According
to Hartman； 〃A。 X。 N。〃 p。 350； 〃ridicule detorquet Hesiodeum〃：
｛outos men panaristos os auto panta noese esthlos d' au kakeinos os eu
66
… Page 67…
The Sportsman
eiponti pithetai｝。
＇7＇ Al。 〃in true sophistic style。〃 The writer seems to say： 〃I lack
subtlety of expression （nor is that at all my object）； what I do aim at
is to trace with some exactness； to present with the lucidity
appropriate to them； certain thoughts demanded by persons well
educated in the school of virtue。〃
Nor am I singular in thus reproaching the modern type of sophist （not
the true philosopher； be it understood）； it is a general reproach that the
wisdom he professes consists in word…subtleties； not in ideas。＇8＇ Certainly
it does not escape my notice that an orderly sequence of ideas adds beauty
to the composition：＇9＇ I mean it will be easy to find fault with what is
written incorrectly。＇10＇ Nevertheless； I warrant it is written in this fashion
with an eye to rectitude； to make the reader wise and good； not more
sophistical。 For I would wish my writings not to seem but rather to be
useful。 I would have them stand the test of ages